TechcelerateJoin now
Menu
Knowledge base · Validating the idea · Guide 4 of 8

How to analyse competitors and the alternatives customers use today.

Your real competition is whatever customers do now, including spreadsheets, agencies and doing nothing. Map it properly and you will know why anyone would switch.

Competitor analysis at validation stage is not a feature comparison chart for a pitch deck. It is a way of understanding what customers currently do, why they put up with it, and what would make them change. That tells you whether there is room for you and how to position yourself.

Why it matters

Every customer already solves the problem somehow, even if the answer is “we live with it”. Switching has a cost in money, time, retraining and risk. Unless your answer is clearly better on something they care about, they will stay where they are. Understanding the alternatives also guards against the two most common errors: believing there is no competition, and believing you will win on price alone.

Step by step

  1. List every type of alternative. Use five buckets: direct competitors offering a similar product; indirect competitors solving the same problem differently; general tools such as spreadsheets, email and shared drives; people, such as agencies, consultants or an extra hire; and doing nothing.
  2. Ask customers what they have tried. In interviews, ask what they use now, what they tried before and why they stopped. This gives you the alternatives that actually matter, not just the ones that appear in search results.
  3. Research each serious alternative. Read their website, pricing page and product updates. Read reviews, especially the two and three star ones, which tend to be the most specific. Look at their job adverts to see where they are investing. For UK companies, filed accounts and officer details on Companies House give a sense of size and age.
  4. Find the switching triggers. Customers switch at moments: a contract renewal, a new manager, a growth spurt, a compliance change, a painful failure. Note which triggers come up and how often.
  5. Build a comparison on what customers value. Pick the four or five criteria customers mention most, not the features you are proudest of, and rate each alternative honestly.
  6. Write a positioning statement. “For [customer] who [trigger or need], [product] is the [category] that [key benefit], unlike [main alternative], which [main weakness].” If you cannot fill in the last part convincingly, you have more research to do.

Worked example

Docketry wanted to help small conveyancing firms track case milestones. Interviews showed the real alternatives were not other software tools, but a shared spreadsheet, an all-in-one case management system most firms already owned, and a paralegal phoning clients with updates. Their comparison looked like this:

Criterion customers mentionedSpreadsheetCase management systemParalegal calls
Clients see progress without callingNoPartly, clunky portalYes, but costly
Set-up effortLowAlready doneNone
CostVery lowAlready paid forHigh staff time
Fits existing processYesYesYes

The insight was that Docketry should not replace the case management system. It repositioned as a client update layer that plugged into it, and its pitch focused on reducing inbound “where are we?” calls.

Common mistakes

  • Saying “we have no competitors”. It usually means you have not found them, or nobody wants the thing badly enough to try.
  • Comparing features, not outcomes. Customers buy results. A longer feature list rarely wins on its own.
  • Dismissing doing nothing. It is often the strongest alternative because it costs nothing to keep.
  • Planning to win on price. Being cheaper is easy to copy and hard to sustain. Find a difference that matters.
  • Doing it once. Revisit the map every few months; markets move.

What to measure

  • Number of distinct alternatives named by interviewees, and how often each appears.
  • Most common switching triggers and how frequently they occur.
  • Share of interviewees who say they would actively consider switching.
  • Your rating against the main alternative on the top criteria customers named.
With SkilledUp Life

Volunteer analysts can research competitors, collect and tag review data, and keep a living comparison table you can rely on in sales and investor conversations.

How a volunteer team helps with validating the idea · The idea validation team ↗ · How SkilledUp Life works ↗

SkilledUp Life is exclusively for tech companies. Volunteers cannot be paid in any form, including stipends, gift vouchers or expenses. All volunteering is remote, and no promises of paid roles can be made.
Execution Sprint

Idea validation, systematically.

Reading is the start. Members tackle validating the idea in a time-boxed Execution Sprint, alongside tech founders who have built, failed and exited, and leave with measurable results.

Building a tech startup?

Join tech founders who put execution before investment.

Become a member