TechcelerateJoin now
Menu
Knowledge base · Validating the idea · Guide 5 of 8

How to test demand with landing pages, smoke tests and concierge offers.

Interviews tell you what people say. Demand tests show what they do when given a real choice. Run small, honest experiments with a success threshold set in advance.

Once interviews suggest the problem is real, demand tests check whether people will take action when offered a solution. They are cheap, quick and far more reliable than opinions, as long as you design them properly.

Why it matters

People are generous in conversation and careful with their time, data and money. A demand test asks for a small commitment in a realistic setting: leaving an email, booking a call, joining a waitlist with a deposit or using a manual version of the service. The behaviour you observe is evidence you can build on.

Choosing a test

TestWhat it showsTypical effort
Landing pageWhether the message attracts the right people to actDays
Explainer or demo videoWhether the concept is understood and wantedDays
Fake door in an existing product or siteInterest in one specific feature or offerHours
Concierge service, delivered manuallyWhether the outcome is valued enough to keep usingWeeks
Pre-order or depositWillingness to payDays to weeks

Step by step

  1. State the hypothesis and threshold first. For example: “At least 20 per cent of targeted visitors from practice-owner groups will request early access.” Deciding the bar in advance stops you rationalising weak results.
  2. Build a focused landing page. A good page has a headline naming the problem in the customer’s words; a line saying who it is for; three outcomes, not features; an honest indication of price or pricing model; and a single call to action asking for a real commitment, such as booking a 15-minute call. Say clearly that the product is in development.
  3. Send targeted traffic. Share it with the communities and contacts from your interviews, run a small, tightly targeted paid campaign or send it to a list of prospects. Broad traffic gives meaningless conversion rates.
  4. Follow up every sign-up. Send a personal email asking one question, such as “What made you sign up today?” Replies separate real prospects from the curious.
  5. Try a concierge version. Deliver the outcome by hand to a few customers using spreadsheets, email and your own time. If they keep coming back, you have strong evidence of value and a clear view of what to automate first.
  6. Respect marketing rules. If you collect emails, say what you will send and get consent where required. The ICO covers UK GDPR and electronic marketing rules.

Worked example

PlanPantry, a consumer meal-planning idea from two tech founders in Bristol, set a threshold of 8 per cent visitor-to-waitlist conversion from targeted traffic, plus at least ten replies to a follow-up email. They built two landing pages: one about saving money, one about saving time on weeknights. With a small paid campaign aimed at parents in two cities, the time-saving page converted at 11 per cent and the money page at 4 per cent. Seventeen people replied to the follow-up. They then ran a concierge version, emailing personalised weekly plans to 30 households. After six weeks, 19 were still opening every plan, which gave them the confidence, and the content insight, to start building.

Common mistakes

  • Counting vanity sign-ups. An email address from an untargeted visitor tells you very little.
  • No threshold. Without a bar set in advance, every result looks encouraging.
  • Testing too many things at once. Change one variable at a time: the message, the audience or the offer.
  • Misleading people. Never imply a product exists or take payment without being clear about what people will get and when.
  • Running tests for too long. Most demand tests should give a clear answer within two to four weeks.

What to measure

  • Visitor-to-action conversion rate by audience and message.
  • Cost per qualified lead from paid traffic.
  • Reply rate to personal follow-up emails.
  • Retention of concierge customers week by week.
  • Result against the threshold you set before starting.
With SkilledUp Life

Volunteer designers and growth marketers can build landing pages, set up tracking, run small campaigns and help deliver a concierge version while you analyse the results.

How a volunteer team helps with validating the idea · The idea validation team ↗ · How SkilledUp Life works ↗

SkilledUp Life is exclusively for tech companies. Volunteers cannot be paid in any form, including stipends, gift vouchers or expenses. All volunteering is remote, and no promises of paid roles can be made.
Execution Sprint

Idea validation, systematically.

Reading is the start. Members tackle validating the idea in a time-boxed Execution Sprint, alongside tech founders who have built, failed and exited, and leave with measurable results.

Building a tech startup?

Join tech founders who put execution before investment.

Become a member